Are Chimpanzees "Persons"?

Since 2013, the Nonhuman Rights Project has been working on behalf of two chimpanzees, Kiko and Tommy, to have them declared eligible for basic rights—the same as if they were a "person." After all, chimpanzees can recognize themselves in a mirror, communicate through sign language, pursue goals creatively and form long-lasting relationships.

(Currently, the two animals are privately owned. The goal is to have them released to live with other chimpanzees.)

Under current United States law, one is either a "person" or a "thing." There is no third category. In response, the Nonhuman Rights Project argues that if every being must be either a person or a thing, then Kiko and Tommy are persons, not things. In February of this year, a group of philosophers submitted an amicus curiae brief to the New York Court of Appeals in support of legal personhood for Kiko and Tommy. The court is considering whether to allow the case to proceed.

The philosophers admit that the idea of "nonhuman personhood" seems confusing, as we tend to use the two terms synonymously and interchangeably. But, they argue, they are not equivalent. "Human" is best understood "as a biological concept that refers… to a particular species, Homo sapiens. In contrast, 'person' is best understood as a moral and legal concept that refers to an individual who can hold moral and legal rights." There is, they add, "nothing special about species in and of themselves. They are morally arbitrary taxonomic categories."

Click here to continue reading this post and to view the blog archive.

Daily Headline News

Child Data-Privacy Laws Aren't Protecting Kids

A proliferation of free, entertaining online content often leads parents, kids, and tech companies to overlook—or worse, disregard—data-privacy laws. (Johnson, The Atlantic)

more...

With Philadelphia Arrests, Starbucks Again Becomes Focus Of Cultural Debate

As a company that strives to cultivate a warm, inviting atmosphere where people can work and talk, kicking out two black men for asking about the bathroom smacks of hypocrisy and racial profiling. (Wren, NPR)

more...

Facebook to stop teenagers sharing sexual preferences without parent's permission

Those who have created a profile and stated that they are aged between 13 and 15 will be prompted to remove the categories [of religious and sexual preferences] from their profile, or get a parent or guardian to consent to them sharing. (Murphy, The Telegraph)

more...

Kendrick Lamar's "DAMN." Wins Historic Pulitzer Prize In Music

It's the first time in the prize's history that it has been given to an artist outside of the classical or jazz community. (Flanagan, NPR)

more...

Why did Jesus talk to the devil? (And other questions about His actions.)

Whether we have grown up in the church our entire lives or are just starting to explore the Christian faith, we all have questions about Jesus that we're often afraid to ask. For a month prior to the start of this series, people submitted their questions (anonymously) through an online web form. Those questions were then used to build this series called, "Everything You Wanted to Know About Jesus, But Were Afraid to Ask." All of the questions fell into broad themes or areas. The first week tackles the #3 most popular question theme, and each week leads up to the final installment of the series with the #1 most popular question theme.

Click here to see this product and more.